RQ_IrW1CEPi

Looking for a Nonprofit Website Redesign? Here Are 10 Things You Should Know

A website redesign is a chance to make your organization’s work easier to understand and easier to support. It’s also a sizeable project, involving decisions about content, technology, staff time, accessibility, and what happens after launch.

If you’re comparing agencies or preparing to ask for proposals, these ten considerations can help you focus on the parts that matter beyond the new look.

1. Start with strategy, not screen designs

It’s natural to picture colors and layouts first. But design can’t resolve a lack of agreement about who the site is for or what people should be able to do there.

Start by identifying your audiences and their needs. A donor may want to understand your impact and make a gift. Someone looking for services may need eligibility details and a direct way to get help. Staff may need to update program information without waiting for a developer.

Agree on the site’s priorities before moving into design. That gives the team a basis for decisions about navigation, page content, and calls to action. Snowberry’s digital strategy process is built around understanding organizational goals and audience needs before design begins.

2. Audit content before rebuilding it

Moving every old page into a new design is a reliable way to bring old problems along for the ride.

Make a simple inventory of your pages and decide whether each one should be kept, updated, combined, or removed. Check for expired programs, outdated contact details, duplicate content, and pages written in language that makes sense mainly to staff. Look at analytics and search data where available, but also ask the people who answer questions from visitors: what information do people need most?

Plan redirects for important pages whose URLs will change. A redirect map helps visitors and search engines find the right destination after launch. Our guide to common nonprofit website mistakes has more practical checks to consider.

Nonprofit team members reviewing page printouts and organizing content for a website redesign

A useful AI prompt for a first-pass content audit:

I’m reviewing website content for a nonprofit. I’ll share a page’s text and its purpose.

For this page:
1. Summarize what a first-time visitor can learn.
2. Identify details that may be unclear, outdated, duplicated, or written in internal jargon.
3. Suggest whether to keep, update, combine, or remove it, and explain why.
4. List questions our staff must verify before making changes.
5. Suggest a clearer structure without inventing facts or changing the organization’s meaning.

Do not assume information is current. Flag anything that needs human review.

AI can help organize the audit, but it can’t confirm whether a program is still active or whether an impact claim is accurate. Keep those decisions with your team.

3. Know who owns the site when the project ends

Your organization should understand who controls the domain, hosting account, website content, design files, code, analytics, and connected services. Make ownership and access clear in the contract, not just in a friendly conversation.

Keep key accounts in your organization’s name, and make sure more than one appropriate staff member can access them. Ask what files, credentials, documentation, and training you’ll receive at handoff. Also ask how a future transfer to another provider would work. A site you can’t access independently can become a problem when staff or vendors change.

4. Make sure staff can handle everyday edits

If changing a program date requires a developer, your new site may be difficult to keep current. Ask to see how common updates will work in the content editor, not just how the finished pages look.

Consider which tasks staff should be able to do themselves, such as updating service details, adding an event, or changing a staff profile. Ask whether the agency will provide training and guidance, and who your team can contact when an update isn’t straightforward.

WordPress can offer organizations flexibility, but it still needs thoughtful setup and ongoing care. Our guide to WordPress for nonprofits covers the trade-offs.

5. Treat accessibility as a build requirement

Accessibility works best when it shapes the project from the start. It affects design choices, page structure, content, forms, menus, and the tools visitors use to donate or request services.

Ask how the agency will test the site and what accessibility standard is in scope. The W3C’s Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2 provide a recognized framework; many organizations specify Level AA as a target. Automated scans can identify some issues, but they don’t replace hands-on testing, such as checking keyboard navigation and key visitor tasks.

Be specific in the proposal about the testing and remediation you expect. Accessibility is not something a plugin or a final-day scan can simply switch on. For a practical starting point, see our guide to accessible website design.

6. Plan for mobile from the beginning

A mobile-friendly site is more than a desktop layout squeezed onto a smaller screen. Visitors should be able to read content, find navigation, use forms, and complete important tasks without pinching, zooming, or wrestling with tiny controls.

Ask how the agency will review mobile layouts and test real tasks on phones. Include the donation flow, service information, and contact forms in that review. If your team has analytics, look at which pages and actions people use on mobile; that can help prioritize what needs the most attention.

7. Give the donation flow special attention

For many nonprofits, the donation page is one of the most important parts of the website. It deserves more than a quick visual review.

Check how easy it is to find the donate link, understand giving options, complete the form, and tell that the transaction worked. Test the full process on a phone, including error messages and the confirmation page. Check that your donation platform works with your CRM and other tools, and clarify which parts of the experience are controlled by that platform.

Donor experience involves trust as well as usability. The Nielsen Norman Group’s research on nonprofit and charity websites includes guidance on donation processes and the information people look for before giving.

Angled smartphone mockup displaying a clear, simple nonprofit donation form

8. Set a realistic timeline and budget range

A redesign’s schedule depends on more than how quickly an agency can design and build. Scope, content readiness, approvals, integrations, accessibility review, and the availability of staff to provide feedback can all affect timing.

Likewise, budget depends on what the project includes. A refresh of an existing site has different requirements from a new structure, a platform migration, or integrations with donation, membership, or CRM systems. Content writing, brand work, and staff training may also affect the scope.

Ask agencies to explain what their proposed schedule and budget include, what depends on your team, and what could change them. Be wary of estimates that seem precise before anyone has discussed your goals, content, and technical needs.

9. Include ongoing costs in the decision

Launch is not the last time your website will need attention. Software updates, hosting, backups, security monitoring, content changes, and troubleshooting all need an owner and a plan.

Ask what is covered by an ongoing support agreement and what counts as additional work. If your team plans to manage routine updates, find out what training and documentation are included. If you expect to rely on a provider, ask about response times, emergency support, and how work is handled if your main contact is unavailable.

Compare the full cost of operating the site over time, including any third-party tools or licenses, not just the initial project.

10. Choose an agency that asks good questions

A proposal should show that the agency understands your organization’s audiences, priorities, and constraints. Ask how much of its work is with nonprofits or organizations like yours, and request relevant references you can speak with.

Useful questions include:

  • How will you help us set priorities before design starts?
  • How will content, accessibility, and mobile testing fit into the project?
  • What will our staff be able to update after launch?
  • What will we own and receive at handoff?
  • What does ongoing maintenance include, and what costs extra?
  • How will we know whether the redesigned site is working?

Notice whether the agency gives clear answers, explains trade-offs, and listens before recommending a solution. A good fit is not just a portfolio that looks polished; it’s a partner who can help you make sound decisions about the whole project.

Nonprofit staff member learning to update website content with a colleague nearby

A redesign should leave your team in a better position

The right nonprofit website redesign should help visitors understand your work and take the next step, while giving staff a manageable way to keep information current. The planning, content decisions, accessibility work, and handoff are part of that result, not side quests.

If you’re weighing a redesign, start by listing what isn’t working, what visitors need to do, and what your team needs to manage. Then use that list to guide conversations with potential partners. You can learn more about Snowberry Media’s website design and development services or contact us to talk through your project.

explore

Categories

Archives

similar resources

Nonprofit Branding: Why Your Website Doesn’t Match Your Mission (and How to Align Them)

Nonprofit Branding: Why Your Website Doesn’t Match Your Mission (and How to Align Them)

Your nonprofit’s website can be easy to navigate and still feel like it belongs to a different organization. Maybe the colors and photos look dated. Maybe the language sounds more…
Read More
Accessible Website Design: 10 Fixes You Can Ship This Week

Accessible Website Design: 10 Fixes You Can Ship This Week

Website accessibility can sound like a project that needs a new budget, a specialist team, and several months of meetings. Sometimes a larger review is exactly what’s needed. But you…
Read More
When a Theater Got Sued Over Its Website: Accessibility Lessons for Nonprofits

When a Theater Got Sued Over Its Website: Accessibility Lessons for Nonprofits

A website can look perfectly fine to one visitor and still leave another unable to find a show, understand an event, or complete a task. That gap was at the…
Read More
WordPress for Nonprofits: What It’s Great At (and What to Watch Out For)

WordPress for Nonprofits: What It’s Great At (and What to Watch Out For)

A website should make it easier for people to understand your work and take a next step, not make your staff file a ticket every time a program date changes.…
Read More
get a proposal

start a project
with us